Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Bulls on the menu

















At least once every year, I go to see a bull fight. I'm not an aficionado by any means, but I go with people who are. They're not what you'd imagine. One of them is a dedicated conservationist, a man who makes his living protecting the natural environment. Another is a veterinary surgeon. Go figure. I took these photos at the last fight I went to, earlier this year. I was down in the ring behind the barrier, just a few feet from the action, and it was terrifying. Next time I go, I’m toying with the idea of doing something different. I want to watch a bullfight and, once it’s over, I want to buy some bull meat, cook it and eat it. Wait, don’t recoil! There’s more to this than meets the eye.



Let’s start with the fight itself and let’s make no bones about this: It is a cruel spectacle. The bull fight is about life and death, about pain and mortality. It is a carefully-choreographed, violent theatre with a set outcome. Watching a bullfight is a sad experience, but it is one that invites you to confront that emotion, to experience the terrifying beauty of a close call, overshadowed by the lingering inevitability of the final outcome. Of course I can understand why people get up in arms about this. It's not nice. The animal rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals describes it as “a ritualistic slaughter" and a "tradition of tragedy". But for me it goes deeper than that. The buttress of history weighs in behind the bullfight and its symbolism is ingrained in the psyche of many Spaniards. In Spain, the bullfight is considered an art form. Indeed bullfighting critics write in the arts pages of the major national dailies. (Now, you can buy all that, or you can leave it. It's fair to say that most people - even in Spain - choose to leave it. In this context, it's important to note that there's a growing body of public opinion in Spain that wants the bullfight banned.)

To properly experience this spectacle, you need to have at least an inkling of what's going on, of the varying degrees of difficulty of each move as the matador engages with the bull. You need to at least be aware of, if not understand, the connection between the man and the animal, to look beyond the blood and follow every flinching muscle, every smooth turn, every calculated sweep of the red cape. You also need to understand that it takes a big pair of cojones to stand before 600 kilos of pure fury, and that although this guy is about to kill this animal in close combat, the relationship between them is intimate, close.

Remember, too, that it's not just bulls that die in bullrings. Men die too. And very occasionally, a brave, honourable bull that fights well is allowed to live. It is allowed to leave the bullring, not to be shot in a yard out the back, but to spend the rest of its days in wild countryside sowing its proverbial oats. It's rare, but it happens.

And consider this. On average, a Spanish bull lives wild for five or six years before it is fought and killed. It lives in herds, roaming virgin fields and forests that are left untouched and undeveloped purely to breed bulls, an existence as natural as you could get. Contact with humans is kept to a minimum. Now compare that to the short, constrained life of your average farmed cow. You know, just like the one in your burger.

So, despite some reservations, I think I’ve made my mind up. I'm going to try this at least once. In anticipation, I've dug out my Spanish cookery books in search of a recipe for bull meat stew. I’ve found a few, all centred on copious amounts of red wine to produce a thick, rich stew. We’ll see which one I go for, but it’s going to happen soon. In Algeciras, starting on Sunday, it’s feria time. There’ll be bull fights most days for the best part of a week. I have a press pass that will let me watch the action at ground level from the callejon, which is as close as you can get without actually having to wear sparkling pants. The day after each fight, specialist stalls in the market will sell the much sought after meat. The next question is, who do I invite to dinner?

10 comments:

  1. B,

    I am waiting for my invitation to dinner.

    I think that all the recipes for fighting bull meat rely so heavily on lots of wine and heavy stewing because the meat is saturated with adrenaline and lactic acid from the fight, which must affect the taste.

    I share the same views as you when it comes to bulfighting.

    Un abrazo.

    Ty

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't know what to think here: are you saying that because the bull gets to roam wild it is OK to kill it like this? that its death is better than his brother at the slaughterhouse, more noble?

    After watching these documentaries on animals psyche, I am seriously questioning my habits of meat eating. They have found so much more with animals that was originally believed. So what do we kill them and why do we eat them still?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Joumana,

    No, that’s not what I meant to say. It was a statement of fact: bulls live longer and better than your average farmed cow. It’s something people don’t often think about, but it doesn’t make the death of the animal any better or worse.

    This is a difficult subject. I wanted to set out some thoughts on bullfighting. I also wanted to write about the bulls from a food perspective, because not many people know that the meat is considered a delicacy in Spain. It’s a tricky one, I’ll admit, and maybe I didn't get the balance right.

    I’m sorry if I’ve offended you (or anyone else) with this post. It’s just that I believe that if you eat meat – or go to bullfights, for that matter - then you should think about these things. There will be one more on this theme, I’m afraid. Then it’s back to fish.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Brian
    NO OFFENSE there; I love your candidness and I wanted to be just as candid.
    I still eat meat, goat, lamb, chicken, but now I feel bad about it (sometimes)
    Thanks for elaborating!
    Do you know I just read a study in a French magazine: they found what will best feed our planet in the future: grasshoppers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Joumana, I'm glad I didn't offend as it's the last thing I'd want.
    I think I'm a little touchy on this subject for one simple reason: however much I try to intellectualise it, the bottom line is that every time I go to a fight, I'm watching an animal being brutally slaughtered. I can't ignore that uncomfortable fact.
    It might surprise you to know that as a student in the UK, I was a militant vegetarian who used to participate in anti-fox hunting protests. One day I'll blog about what happened to change all that.
    Last thing: I'd happily try grasshoppers, why not? Must be a bit like prawns no? :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ty, bro. You know that if you were here, you'd be in the kitchen helping me cook while downing a nice bottle (or three) of Rioja. I've yet to buy the meat but I went to the first fight on Sunday. It was OK, nothing spectacular, though Ponce was carried out the main gate for his second bull. My photos filled two pages and the front page in El Faro, which was cool. See the piece here: http://www.andaluciainformacion.es/portada/?a=129133&i=17&f=0

    ReplyDelete
  7. What can I say I'm in the text! but I do like the idea, from the campo to the plato via the sand.

    ReplyDelete
  8. watch out Eric, at this rate you'll wangle a dinner invitation...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wangle I thought I was on the list, you just cannot carry on eating all this food by your self, you know you need help!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Brian, Send my invite in the mail! As a matter of fact, I'll meet you at the plaza!

    ReplyDelete